Plush Toys

Refine Your Choices for Plush Toys

Accessories & Apparel

Cleaning & Grooming

Crates & Furniture

Food & Nutrition

Training & Behavior

Travel & Outdoor

Sort By

Look Who's Talking Plush Animal Friends

$5.19
$4.15 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Multipet Loofa Dog

$2.48
$1.98 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Multipet Plush Flea

$7.79
$6.23 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Skinneez Plush Squirrel Dog Toy

$6.84
$5.47 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Booda Plush Hedgehog

$6.30
$5.04 w/code CARE20

Shop

Every pet needs their toys. This soft Booda Plush Hedgehog has the durability to withstand the sharpest of teeth, plus did we mention the squeaker inside? See More »
Tuffy's Barn Yard - Polly the Pig

$22.34
$17.87 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Skinneeez Plush Jungle Cat

$6.34
$5.07 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Skinneeez Plush Chicken 18"

$8.66
$6.93 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Petstages Big Squeak Elephant

$14.35
$11.48 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Multipet Mr. Bill SNL Plush Toy

$7.20
$5.76 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Tuffy's Tuff-Scale - Captain Kurklops

$20.54
$16.43 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Plush Sport Ball - Soccer Ball

$3.30
$2.64 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Dr. Noys Replacement Squeakers

$1.49
$1.19 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Skinneeez Plush Fox

$5.72
$4.58 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Multipet Swinging Safari 22"

$7.46
$5.97 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Vermont Fleece Rabbit 9"

$10.08
$8.06 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Petstages Cool Teething Stick

$5.51
$4.41 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Kong Plush Snake

$10.39
$8.31 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Petstages Big Squeak Gator

$8.52
$6.82 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Tuffy's Barn Yard Bevo the Bull

$35.48
$28.38 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Vermont Fleece Chewman

$9.69
$7.75 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Multipet Plush Tick Toy

$8.39
$6.71 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Tuffy's Barn Yard - Sherman the Sheep

$20.98
$16.78 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Booda Soft Bite Hedgehog - Large

$5.51
$4.41 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Booda Squatters - Hedgehog

$3.89
$3.11 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Multipet Birthday Cake 5.5"

$6.75
$5.40 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Booda Squatters - Panda/Rabbit 2Pack

$5.45
$4.36 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Skinneeez Plush Skunk 24"

$7.79
$6.23 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Kong Frog Squeaker

$3.50
$2.80 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Kong Platy Duck

$3.89
$3.11 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
American Classic Plush Rabbit

$8.88
$7.10 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »
Multipet Empty Nesters Canadian Goose 18"

$7.49
$5.99 w/code CARE20

Shop

See More »

EV SSL Certificate