Ever since dogs first came into
contact with humans, they have been serving us in
extraordinary ways. Dogs are not only our companions, they can
also herd, help us hunt, and be trained to work as service dogs, therapy dogs, police dogs, and military dogs. And according to recent
studies, dogs can now provide another benefit to humans by
allowing us to study their diseases.
Disease-Causing Genes
Domestic dogs can suffer from hundreds of the same diseases as
people can, and the diseases present in similar ways. While that
may not be a happy thought, what it means is that we can study
our four-legged friends in order to better understand and find
new therapies for human hereditary diseases.
Dogs are great study subjects because they make it easy to find
disease-causing genes (much easier than it is in people). This is
because domestic breeding of dogs has resulted in some
inbreeding, and thus the spread of certain disease-causing genes
within certain breeds.
This type of breeding also means that all dogs within a certain
breed are genetically similar, and therefore disease-causing
genes can be identified in smaller groups of dogs as opposed to
thousands of human patients and controls.
More Than Just Genes
Dogs are useful in studying human diseases not only because we
can examine their disease-causing genes, but also because they
share our environments.
This is important because things in our environments -- including
stressors and what we eat -- can
directly impact how genes are expressed, and so environmental
factors that influence disease formation in humans can also
affect our dogs.
RELATED
STORY: Diets To
Treat Cat And Dog Stress
Weโre Seeing ResultsThe study of diseases in dogs has already had
some amazing results. Some studies have influenced the
development of a new gene therapy for hemophilia, and another
study that identified the genetic basis of narcolepsy in dogs allowed researchers to
discover a previously unknown pathway in the brain.
It will be fascinating to see what else this partnership between
human and veterinary medicine can accomplish.
Read the BBCโs
full article.
Scientists Slam Supplements for Humans, What's That Mean for
Pets?
Vitamins and supplements have taken a beating recently -- a Dec
17 editorial published in
Annals of
Internal Medicine
claimed "Enough is enough: stop wasting money on vitamin and
mineral supplements."Strong words! But what exactly was
researched, and what does that mean for the supplements people
use, and the ones they give to their pets?
Generalizations of Three Studies
The widely-publicized paper was in fact a study of other studies
-- an effort to gather information from three different research
projects on supplements, and provide a conclusive answer. The
problem here, as
many have pointed out
, is that the three studies chosen weren't the only ones, or even
necessarily the best, and the conclusions drawn were perhaps
pushed into a jazzy headline.
The Nitty Gritty
The first study reviewed in the paper focused on vitamins and
minerals meant to reduce heart attack, stroke, or need for heart
surgery*. The supplements reduced these events by 11
percent, as compared to a placebo. Because this percentage is not
considered statistically significant, the
Annals
paper concluded that the treatment was ineffective -- but what
"not statistically significant" really means is that we can be
less than 95 percent certain that the effect was real.The second
study focused on cognitive brain function in men and
the daily use of a low-potency multivitamin (Centrum
Silver)**. The 8.5 year study found that the multivitamin had no
effect. The paper failed to mention two other recent trials,
however -- ones which found positive effects***.The
third study was in itself a review of research examining
whether vitamin and mineral supplements can prevent heart disease
or cancer. Two large studies failed to find a beneficial effect
to the heart disease supplements being taken. The research
did find a statistically significant 7 percent reduction in
cancer incidence in men, though, and interestingly, no effect in
women****. Sounds like reason for more investigation to some, as
opposed to a reason to announce "case closed."
What Wasn't Covered
Basically everything not mentioned above. Studying the heart
health, cancer prevention, and brain function benefits of several
vitamins certainly covers a lot of ground, but in the end, is
only the beginning of a complex issue.Alan R. Gaby, M.D., past
president of the
American Holistic
Medical Association cautions
that
"Simply dismissing a vast body of research because the results
are conflicting is not useful."
What About Supplements for Pets?
Nothing in the December study focused on vitamins and supplements
specifically used for pets, like
glucosamine and
chondroitin and fish
oil
. Your vet is still your best resource for advice on what
supplements might be beneficial to your pet.
-
Glucosamine is
an amino sugar naturally produced and found in pets' cartilage.
It helps cartilage perform two of its main functions:
lubrication and shock absorption. Chondroitin is a
carbohydrate naturally produced in animal cartilage. It keeps
cartilage hydrated, and also helps inhibit some of the enzymes
in the joints that degrade cartilage.
-
Fish oil for
dogs and cats has been shown to support the health of the skin,
coat, joint, kidneys, heart, and immune system. In some
studies, itโs even been shown to slow the growth of cancer.
What Do You Think?
Have you found supplements useful for yourself, or your pets?
Share you opinion in the comments below!
*Lamas GA, et al. Oral high-dose multivitamins and minerals
after myocardial infarction: a randomized trial. Ann Intern Med
2013;159:797-804.
**Grodstein F, et al. Long-term multivitamin supplementation
and cognitive function in men: a randomized trial. Ann Intern Med
2013;159:806-814.
***Walker JG, et al. Oral folic acid and vitamin B-12
supplementation to prevent cognitive decline in
community-dwelling older adults with depressive symptoms - the
Beyond Ageing Project: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Clin
Nutr 2012;95:194-203, and Smith AD, et al.
Homocysteine-lowering by B vitamins slows the rate of accelerated
brain atrophy in mild cognitive impairment: a randomized
controlled trial. PLoS One 2010;5(9):e12244.
****Fortmann SP, et al. Vitamin and mineral supplements in
the primary prevention of cardiovascular disease and cancer: an
update systematic evidence review for the U.S. Preventive
Services Task Force. Ann Intern Med 2013;159:824-834.
---
For all the good that dogs can do for us, we should do good
for them, too. Take care of your petโs health by keeping up with
veterinary visits, and consider
signing up for PetPlus
to save on your petโs medications, boarding, and more.