Does Your Dog Prefer a Belly Rub Over a Treat?

Does Your Dog Prefer a Belly Rub Over a Treat?

Image Credit

When humans started the process of domesticating dogs, they practically laid the groundwork for a strong and enduring cross species social bond that would only get stronger over time. Wherever humans go, dogs are wont to follow. If it has ever occurred to you that dogs are more interested in you than the treat in your hand, you'd be glad to know that it is not entirely in your imagination.Animal researchers at Emory University just discovered that dogs value affection more than food. Animal trainers who have successfully trained dog to perform tasks to food rewards might find this a little hard to believe. But science seems to disagree. The results of the study were published in a paper that explored the subject of treats versus praise in detail, and they incontrovertibly point to the fact that dogs do find human affection more intrinsically rewarding. Apart from reminding us of the social origins of dogs as a species, this discovery could also provide a lot of valuable tools for training working dogs. It bears mentioning that this is not the first study of its kind, but it does certainly add a lot to our understanding of dog behavior.

Three experiments

The researchers involved in the study used functional magnetic resonance imaging in 15 wide awake dogs to explore the neural basis behind their preferences for food reward and social interaction. In the first experiment, they used readings of the ventral caudate as a statistical measure of intrinsic reward and compared the region's activation to conditioned stimuli like praise, food or nothing. Compared to the control stimulus, it was observed that the caudate was much more active to rewards and even more so when it came to praise. This was uniformly the case in 13 of the 15 participating dogs.The second experiment was done to confirm the results of the first. To make sure that the differences in the readings was driven by the intrinsic value of praise, they withheld the praise on a subsection of trials. They noticed that there were considerable differences in the degree of caudate activation relative to withholding praise and the results had a very strong correlation to the differential activation in response to the conditioned stimuli in the first experiment.In a final experiment, they had the participating dogs complete a Y-shaped maze in which they had to choose a treat or their owner. The results of the MRI scans correctly predicted their response here as well, thereby demonstrating that this trait has deep-seated biological routes.The testing was done over a number of sessions to make sure that the dogs get a break in between and do not get tired of being handled or frustrated of the food. Since the responses were consistent across the sessions, it is not just an afternoon whim that drove the dogs to prefer praise to treats. This study conclusively proves that early socialization and positive enforcement is much more important than the food we dole out to our dogs during meal time.

How Belly Rubs Are Taking The World By Storm


We all know that pooches love a good scratch behind the ears or a belly rub. But did you know that the action is even therapeutic for humans, too? It has a real, quantifiable calming effect, which is why many canines are finding themselves employed by hospitals and senior centers to visit patients during the day. However, in other parts of the world belly rubs, or any form of dog petting, are expressly forbidden.

In fact, Malaysia recently erupted after a dog petting festival turned ugly. The organizer, Syed Azmi Alhabshi, even received threats on his life from enraged citizens. Time magazine reported that he has been forced into hiding after religious conservatives protested his "I Want to Touch a Dog" event that was held in Bandar Utama, an affluent neighborhood in Kuala Lumpur. More than 1,000 showed up to relax and play with various pooches. Alhabshi's goal was to have visitors learn about Islam's views on canines and become familiar with dogs, as they're typically shunned over the fear of contracting diseases. Many Malaysians own dogs for security purposes due to rising crime waves in the country. Muslims can have canines as working animals for hunting and other functions, too. Issues with canines date back to the Colonial era in Malaysia, when an influx of dogs was brought by British officials. This made pooches fashionable among wealthy Malaysians, including members of the royal family. But the event was coordinated to introduce citizens to the calming effect that petting a pooch can have on people.

What are the best spots to pet your dog?

While the Malaysian debate rages on, pet owners around the world continue to love and cuddle their furry friends. Scratching or rubbing the right spot can send them into a frenzy, kicking their legs in enjoyment. But do you know which spots you should aim for to get the best reactions?In some instances, the age of your pooch can play a role in where you pet him. According to Pets Adviser,gently massaging a puppy's mouth and gums not only shows affection, but allows fresh blood to flow into the area. Oral health is important for canines, as plaque buildup can cause significant heart issues down the road. In addition, rubbing a puppy's paws might make nail trimmings more manageable as he's more used to the sensation.While most dogs will have their own preferences, many of them enjoy a good belly rub or a scratch on the neck that leads down to their spines. However, it's important that you don't try to pet a dog while he's barking, as he may get frightened and try to bite you.Owners should consider a PetPlus membership because it grants them access to dozens of discounted supplements that can keep your pooch just as happy as a full body massage.

Was this article helpful?

You May Also Like

Image for Large Dog Grooming Tips
Large Dog Grooming Tips

To Keep Your Large or Giant Breed Dog Groomed and Clean

Read More